Mastering AppSec Maturity: A Comprehensive Guide to Elevating Your Application Security

by Sri Sarma


So you’ve got your AppSec programme up and running: good stuff. You’re well on the way to protecting your application data and code against cyberattacks and threats.

Now it’s time to focus on maturity. Achieving AppSec maturity means going further than basic application security awareness. It’s about putting security first throughout the application development lifecycle and continuously improving your processes.

In a nutshell, AppSec maturity is the gradual development and enhancement of an organisation’s application security practices and capabilities. To mature your practice, you need to move beyond foundational security measures to a more advanced, systematic, and proactive approach. You should adopt an approach of “learning to walk before you run” to ensure you are able to meet your milestones with support from all functions involved.

This involves getting stakeholders involved and gaining their confidence to integrate security more deeply into your software development lifecycle, continuously iterating on key metrics and feedback, automating processes wherever possible, and generally fostering a security-aware culture among developers and other stakeholders.

AppSec maturity is the evolution from reactive, ad-hoc security measures to comprehensive, well-structured, and efficient security programmes—ones that anticipate and mitigate risks effectively, long before they can cause issues.

Why you should be measuring your AppSec maturity

Implementing AppSec processes is not a one-and-done job. To make the most of your practice and fully exploit the potential that AppSec offers in our increasingly cybercrime-ridden world, you need to aim for maturity.

Climbing up that maturity ladder means constantly evaluating your AppSec practice’s performance. Measuring your current maturity will help you get a clear understanding of your existing security posture and scope out areas that need improvement.

Measuring AppSec maturity isn’t about running meaningless reports; it’s a strategic approach that helps your business systematically enhance security capabilities, recognise, prioritise and reduce risks, and maintain a robust defence against cyber threats.

By measuring your organisation’s AppSec maturity, you can:

  1. Identify gaps and weaknesses: By regularly assessing your maturity, your organisation can pinpoint specific areas where AppSec practices may be lagging behind, giving you the information you need to make targeted improvements.
  2. Improve resource allocation: Understanding maturity also helps to prioritise security investments and resources more effectively, meaning the most critically deficient areas receive attention first.
  3. Achieve better risk management: A well-monitored AppSec programme reduces the risk of security breaches and vulnerabilities, protecting your business from potential financial, legal, and reputational damage.
  4. Facilitate continuous improvement: Measuring maturity helps you build a culture of continuous improvement, where regular updates and enhancements to security practices in response to evolving threats become second nature.
  5. Set realistic goals: Analysing data about your AppSec practice allows you to benchmark your security practices against industry standards and set realistic, measurable goals for improvement (rather than just plucking targets out of the air).
  6. Boost stakeholder confidence: Measuring AppSec maturity shows a clear commitment to improving your security processes; showcasing your commitment to safeguarding sensitive information in this way can go a long way towards building trust and confidence among customers, partners, and stakeholders.

What benefits does a mature AppSec practice offer?

Why is a mature AppSec practice worth working towards, and what kind of benefits can you expect as you build on your maturity? Operating a mature AppSec practice offers a whole range of advantages that can enhance your organisation’s overall security posture, operational efficiency, and even your brand reputation.

Let’s take a look at a few of the most impactful benefits that mature AppSec practices can deliver.

  1. Enhanced security posture: Obvious but worth mentioning, because the impact can be so enormous. Mature AppSec practices create stronger defences against cyber threats, reducing the likelihood of successful attacks on applications that can result in data breaches and huge financial consequences.
  2. Lower risk: The more mature your AppSec practice is, the better you’ll be at identifying and addressing vulnerabilities early in the development process. As a result, mature AppSec minimises the risk of exploitation and the financial, legal, and reputational damage that comes with it. Plus, a mature approach tends to include thorough risk assessments, threat modelling, and proactive measures, all of which add up to a more comprehensive and strategic risk management framework.
  3. Cost efficiency: They say prevention is better than cure, and that certainly applies to AppSec. Proactively integrating security into the development lifecycle and heading off any potential issues is far more cost-effective than addressing bugs post-deployment. This pre-emptive approach helps reduce costs incurred by emergency fixes, breach responses, and downtime.
  4. Regulatory compliance: Mature AppSec practices often align closely with data protection laws, privacy regulations and industry security standards, helping your business avoid financial penalties and meet its compliance requirements with less effort.
  5. Faster time-to-market: Mature AppSec leans heavily on automation to improve the quality and efficiency of security processes. By automating security processes and integrating them into the CI/CD pipeline, you can reduce delays and get secure, stable applications out into the world more quickly.
  6. More productive Developers: With security integrated into their workflows and tools, developers can spend more time focusing on secure coding, instead of fighting security-related fires, which has a massively positive effect on overall productivity. The ability to develop secure code becomes second nature for developers and they are more inclined to up their game if they are well supported.
  7. Resilience and adaptability: Mature AppSec practices incorporate continuous monitoring and improvement into the SSD-SDLC, making your organisation more resilient to evolving threats and helping your team be better prepared to adapt to new security challenges as they arise.
  8. Employee awareness: A culture of security awareness and responsibility is at the heart of all mature AppSec practices. Employees are encouraged to adopt and iterate on best practices, awareness of security threats is high, and vigilance is maintained across the organisation.
  9. Competitive advantage: In a fast-moving market, businesses with truly mature AppSec practices can easily differentiate themselves by offering more secure products and services and gaining a competitive edge through the trust and customer satisfaction that a high level of security engenders.

The 4 tiers of AppSec maturity

Ready to give your AppSec maturity a boost? The first step on your journey to maturity is understanding what you’re aiming for—and that’s where the AppSec maturity model comes in.

The AppSec maturity model provides a simple framework that helps organisations assess, develop, and enhance their application security practices. The model typically consists of four tiers, each representing a different level of maturity. By using these tiers to benchmark your current AppSec practice’s maturity, you can work out where you stand and what you need to do to get up to the next level of AppSec awesomeness.

Here’s what you need to know:

Tier 0: Awareness

This first tier focuses on building a fundamental understanding of application security within the organisation’s application development processes and sets the groundwork for developing more advanced security practices.

AppSec practices operating at a Tier 1 level will have:

Basic security awareness

  • At this stage, the organisation recognises the importance of application security but hasn’t yet gotten around to implementing structured or formalised security processes.
  • Their primary goal will be to create a baseline awareness of security principles and the need for security measures among all employees, especially those involved in software development.
  • Initiatives might include informal discussions, basic security documentation, and introductory presentations on the importance of application security.

Aspirations to create a mature AppSec practice

  • The organisation will have a growing understanding that application security needs to be a priority, and leaders and key stakeholders will express a desire to establish and mature AppSec practices.
  • Their focus will be on building a case for investing in security and planning the initial steps towards developing a structured security programme.
  • Initiatives might involve setting long-term security goals, identifying champions within the business to lead security efforts, and allocating preliminary resources for security initiatives.

Plans to determine maturity

  • The organisation will be starting to assess its current security posture to understand where it stands in terms of application security maturity.
  • It will aim to evaluate existing security practices (or the lack thereof) and determine the starting point for improvement.
  • Initiatives could include informal assessments, surveys, or discussions to gather information on current security awareness, practices, and gaps.

Completed team security training

  • The organisation will introduce formal security training to enhance the knowledge and skills of development teams and other relevant personnel.
  • It will aim to provide foundational security education and ensure that team members understand basic security concepts, common threats, and best practices.
  • Training programmes might include online courses, workshops, seminars, and access to security resources. Topics typically covered would be secure coding practices, common vulnerabilities (like those in the OWASP Top Ten), and basic threat modelling.

Tier 1 (Foundational)

This foundational tier focuses on establishing essential security practices and implementing tools to create a strong security foundation within the development process.

AppSec practices operating at a Tier 1 level will have:

Developed and implemented a secure coding practice

  • The organisation will have a set of secure coding standards and guidelines, tailored to its development environment and technology stack, that ensure secure coding practices are actively applied in the development process.
  • It will have created and disseminated secure coding manuals, checklists, and best practice guidelines to be followed by developers.
  • It will conduct code reviews and peer reviews with a focus on security, using established secure coding guidelines.

Implemented security training for Developers

  • The organisation will provide targeted training sessions to educate developers on security principles, common vulnerabilities, and secure coding practices.
  • It will offer regular training programmes, workshops, and online courses focused on security awareness and skill development.

Ongoing plans to determine maturity

  • The organisation will continuously assess and evaluate the effectiveness of its foundational security practices.
  • It will carry out regular reviews and updates to ensure that security measures are being effectively implemented and followed.

A schedule of regular scans

  • The organisation will conduct regular security scans to identify and remediate vulnerabilities.
  • Scheduled SAST, SCA, and DAST scans will be integrated into the development lifecycle, with processes in place for addressing identified issues.

Implemented SAST, SCA, and DAST at minimum

  • Static Application Security Testing (SAST): Integrates static code analysis tools to identify insecure code during development that might lead to potential vulnerabilities.
  • Software Composition Analysis (SCA): Implements tools to manage and secure third-party and open-source components by identifying vulnerabilities and licencing
  • Dynamic Application Security Testing (DAST): Uses dynamic analysis tools to find security issues in running applications, simulating real-world attacks.

Tier 2 (Proactive)

This tier focuses on proactively identifying and mitigating security risks throughout the software development lifecycle.

AppSec practices operating at a Tier 2 level will have:

Threat modelling in place

  • The organisation will conduct systematic threat modelling to identify, evaluate, and mitigate potential security threats.
  • It will carry out regular threat modelling sessions during the design phase of projects to anticipate and plan for security risks.

Secure design reviews

  • The organisation will review application architecture and design with a focus on security to ensure that security is built in from the start.
  • It will hold formal design review meetings with security experts, incorporating security considerations into design documentation.

A secure software development cycle (SSDF)

  • The organisation will have adopted a secure software development framework (SSDF) to integrate security into every phase of the SDLC.
  • It will ensure the implementation of secure development practices, continuous integration of security tools, and secure coding standards.

Implemented policies, standards and GRC

  • The organisation will have developed and will enforce security policies, standards, and governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) frameworks.
  • This could include the creation of security policies, regular audits, and compliance checks to ensure adherence to secure coding practices.

Ongoing maturity determination

  • The organisation will continuously evaluate the maturity of proactive security practices.
  • It will conduct regular assessments, feedback loops, and updates to security processes based on findings.

SSD framework integrated into the development cycle

  • The organisation will have fully integrated the SSD framework into the development process, ensuring security is a core component.
  • It will continuously integrate security checks and practices throughout the SDLC, from planning to deployment.

Continuous scanning

  • The organisation will implement continuous security scanning to identify and address vulnerabilities in real-time.
  • These may include automated and continuous SAST, SCA, and DAST scans integrated into the CI/CD pipeline.

Time-bound remediation

  • The organisation will have established strict timelines for remediating identified security issues.
  • It will set and enforce deadlines for fixing vulnerabilities, with tracking and reporting mechanisms also in place.

Tier 3 (Continuous Improvement)

This final tier focuses on continuously enhancing security practices, automating processes, and responding proactively to incidents.

AppSec practices operating at a Tier 3 level will, at minimum, have:

Regular pen testing

  • The organisation will conduct regular penetration testing to identify vulnerabilities that automated tools might miss.
  • This may include engaging internal or external pen testers to simulate attacks and assess the security posture of applications.

Security gate automation

  • The organisation will have automated security gates to enforce security policies and checks at various stages of the development process.
  • This may include the implementation of automated security checks within the CI/CD pipeline to ensure compliance before the code moves to the next stage.

Secure and managed CI/CD pipelines

  • The organisation works to ensure that CI/CD pipelines are secure and managed with integrated security controls.
  • This may include continuous monitoring and management of CI/CD pipelines to prevent security misconfigurations and vulnerabilities.

Integration with a bug-tracking system

  • The organisation will integrate security tools and findings with bug-tracking systems to streamline vulnerability management.
  • Automation can also be leveraged in this area to automatically create and track security issues within the bug-tracking system, facilitating more efficient remediation.

Ongoing maturity determination

  • The organisation will regularly evaluate the maturity of security practices to ensure continuous improvement.
  • This will include ongoing assessments and updates to security processes based on new threats, vulnerabilities, and best practices.

Automated security checks

  • The organisation will have implemented automated security checks throughout the development and deployment process.
  • This may include the use of automated tools for continuous scanning, monitoring, and enforcement of security policies.

Proactive response to incidents

  • The organisation will have established processes for proactive and rapid response to security incidents.
  • This may include the development and implementation of incident response plans, regular drills, and continuous monitoring to detect and respond to incidents swiftly.

Continuous improvements to the AppSec practice

  • The organisation will emphasise ongoing refinement and enhancement of security practices.
  • This may include regularly reviewing and updating security policies, practices, and tools based on feedback, new threats, and industry developments.

Boost your AppSec maturity with RiverSafe

When you need additional expertise in application security, our team of experienced security engineers is ready to support you, using their deep product security knowledge to seamlessly augment your existing teams.

Reach out to our expert team for personalised AppSec solutions that match your organisation’s unique needs.

Find out more

By Sri Sarma